Unveiling Louisiana’s Use of Nitrogen in Controversial Execution Decision

White building with large columns and sculptures outside

Louisiana has executed Jessie Hoffman Jr. using nitrogen gas for the 1996 rape and murder of Mary Elliot, marking the state’s first execution in 15 years and its first-ever use of this controversial method.

Key Takeaways

  • Louisiana executed Jessie Hoffman Jr. by nitrogen gas, resuming capital punishment after a 15-year hiatus.
  • The Supreme Court declined to intervene in a narrow 5-4 vote, rejecting Hoffman’s religious freedom claims.
  • Louisiana officials described the execution as “flawless” despite reports that Hoffman convulsed for about two minutes.
  • The state plans to execute at least four more death row inmates this year according to Attorney General Liz Murrill.
  • The execution marks the fifth in the U.S. using nitrogen gas, following four in Alabama.

Louisiana Resumes Capital Punishment After 15-Year Gap

Louisiana executed Jessie Hoffman Jr. using nitrogen gas, ending a 15-year pause in the state’s execution program. Hoffman, convicted of the 1996 abduction, rape, and murder of Mary Elliot, became the seventh person executed in the United States this year. The execution took place after Governor Jeff Landry’s administration pushed to restart capital punishment as part of a broader tough-on-crime agenda. Hoffman was executed by pumping nitrogen gas into a mask he wore for 19 minutes, causing death by oxygen deprivation.

Officials from the Louisiana Department of Corrections reported that Hoffman declined to give a final statement before his execution. According to prison officials, he convulsed for approximately two minutes after the gas was administered, though they believe he was likely unconscious during these convulsions. The state’s attorney general and governor’s office had representatives present, along with prison officials, a coroner, a physician, a chaplain, family members of the victim, and reporters.

Legal Challenges and Supreme Court Decision

Hoffman’s lawyers mounted several legal challenges to stop the execution, arguing that the nitrogen hypoxia method violated both the Eighth Amendment prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment and Hoffman’s religious freedom as a Buddhist. The attorneys claimed the nitrogen gas would interfere with his breathing and meditation practices during his final moments. These arguments ultimately reached the Supreme Court, which declined to intervene in a narrow 5-4 vote just moments before the scheduled execution.

Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill declared that with Hoffman’s execution, “justice will finally be served.” The state’s decision to proceed despite legal challenges reflects a renewed commitment to capital punishment under the current administration. Judge Richard “Chip” Moore had previously rejected Hoffman’s religious freedom claims at the state level before the case moved to federal courts and ultimately to the Supreme Court.

Nitrogen Gas: A Controversial Execution Method

The nitrogen hypoxia execution method involves strapping the inmate to a gurney and administering pure nitrogen gas through a respirator mask, causing death by oxygen deprivation. Louisiana expanded its execution options in 2024 to include nitrogen hypoxia and electrocution due to difficulties obtaining drugs for lethal injections. Officials have claimed the method is painless, with one describing Hoffman’s execution as “flawless” and another saying it “went about as good as we could have expected it to be.”

Currently, five states authorize execution by nitrogen hypoxia: Louisiana, Alabama, Mississippi, Oklahoma, and Arkansas. Alabama pioneered the method’s use with four previous executions. Critics argue the method causes distress and slow suffocation, while a small group of execution opponents held a “Meditation for Peace” vigil outside the prison during Hoffman’s execution. The use of alternative execution methods has been increasing nationwide, with South Carolina recently conducting a death by firing squad.

Future of Capital Punishment in Louisiana

Attorney General Liz Murrill has indicated that Louisiana plans to execute at least four more death row inmates this year. This marks a significant shift for the state, which had not carried out an execution since 2010. The resumption of capital punishment in Louisiana comes at a time when the national trend has been moving in the opposite direction, with executions declining due to legal challenges, drug shortages, and reduced public support.

The number of executions nationwide has decreased significantly over the past few decades. However, Louisiana’s renewed commitment to capital punishment, along with its adoption of nitrogen gas as an execution method, signals a potential countertrend in certain states. As Attorney General Murrill and Governor Landry fulfill their campaign promises to be tough on crime, the debate over capital punishment and execution methods will likely continue to divide Americans along ethical, legal, and political lines.

Sources:

Louisiana Resumes Capital Punishment With First Nitrogen Execution

Louisiana puts man to death in state’s first nitrogen gas execution

Louisiana death row killer Jessie Hoffman becomes state’s first nitrogen gas execution

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR