Shocking Email Scam: Real Orders, Fake Purchases

Person reading a scam message on a smartphone.

A new wave of fraudulent emails is exploiting legitimate retailer systems, raising red flags for online shoppers and cybersecurity experts alike.

Story Snapshot

  • Scammers use real tracking numbers for fraudulent order emails.
  • Emails appear legitimate but are linked to unauthorized purchases.
  • The tactic misuses active email addresses to bypass fraud filters.
  • Consumers face increased risks of identity misuse and phishing.

Scammers Exploit Legitimate Retailer Systems

In an alarming trend, scammers are sending out legitimate-looking order shipment emails using real tracking numbers from reputable retailers. These emails, which detail purchases the recipient never made, are part of a sophisticated fraud tactic that misuses active email addresses. This method allows scammers to bypass traditional retailer fraud detection systems, which often focus on flagging suspicious or inactive email addresses.

The emails don’t result in direct financial theft from the recipient, but they do misuse the recipient’s email address as a contact point. The real tracking numbers and delivery details included in these communications make them appear authentic, further complicating the task for retailers and consumers to distinguish between legitimate and fraudulent notifications. This tactic has seen a significant rise since late 2023, with incidents becoming more frequent throughout 2024 and continuing into 2025.

Implications for Consumers and Retailers

The misuse of email addresses in these scams not only creates confusion and anxiety for consumers but also poses significant challenges for retailers. Customer support teams face increased workloads as they handle inquiries and investigate fraudulent orders. Additionally, the potential for malicious links in these emails represents further risks, such as phishing or malware attacks, which can compromise consumer data and privacy even without direct financial theft.

For retailers, this scam undermines trust in their communications with customers. The growing sophistication of these fraudulent tactics pressures companies to enhance their fraud detection systems and invest in better security measures. As a result, the financial and reputational impact on retailers can be substantial, with increased operational costs and potential losses from undetected fraud.

Long-Term Effects and Industry Response

Long-term, these scams could erode consumer trust in all order-related communications, making individuals wary of legitimate emails. The success of this method may inspire further innovations in scam techniques, posing evolving challenges for the e-commerce sector. Consequently, there is a pressing need for industry-wide collaboration on fraud prevention and improved cybersecurity measures.

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and cybersecurity experts have issued consumer alerts, advising vigilance and caution when handling unexpected emails. They recommend verifying order details through official retailer channels and exercising caution before clicking on any links. Retailers are similarly updating their fraud detection protocols to address these emerging threats effectively.

Sources:

First Lockhart National Bank, 2025

FTC Consumer Alerts, 2023

Norton LifeLock, 2024

Scamicide, 2025